...I knew the care was expensive, but I didn't have to worry about that. I needed the care and I got it.... My family has had the care it needed. Other families have not, simply because they could not afford it....
Dennis Kucinich has
added an amendment in The House that would allow states to run their own single-payer systems, but who knows if that addition will survive all the deal making and compromises that we'll see in the next few months. "Everyone won't be satisfied—and no one will get everything they want," Kennedy writes, but he is optimistic. "If we don't get every provision right, we can adjust and improve the program next year or in the years to come. What we can't afford is to wait another generation." The battle for health care is old, and the arguments against it are tired. Kennedy's piece in
Newsweek provides some context. "In 1912, when Theodore Roosevelt ran for a third term as president, the platform of his newly created Progressive Party called for national health insurance," Kennedy notes. "Harry Truman proposed it again more than 30 years after Roosevelt was defeated. The plan was attacked, not for the last time, as 'socialized medicine,' and members of Truman's White House staff were branded 'followers of the Moscow party line.'"
Meanwhile the mudslinging going on is in full force, and the reformers are hitting back. "At this moment -- when 72 percent of the nation supports a public plan option and 14,000 people lose their healthcare every day -- the House Blue Dogs and conservative Democratic Senators are doing just about everything they can to cripple real health care reform," Katrina Vanden Heuvel
wrote recently in her blog at
The Nation.
'Though issues with The Blue Dogs may be
exaggerated, The Finance Committee's compromise bill would
cover too few people and shift the costs to the middle class. That bill would certainly sustain the "torment" Senator Kennedy recounts of the individual families who have to sell everything they own to pay for health care in "the richest country in the world."
Most Americans expect the U.S. to
lead the other advanced nations. Why are we so far behind in keeping our citizens healthy?
An
editorial in
The Globe by Paul Dutton proposes France as a model:
Although the French system faces many challenges, the World Health Organization rated it the best in the world in 2001 because of its universal coverage, responsive healthcare providers, patient and provider freedoms, and the health and longevity of the country's population. The United States ranked 37....
Moreover, in contrast to Canada and Britain, there are no waiting lists for elective procedures and patients need not seek pre-authorizations. In other words, like in the United States, "rationing" is not a word that leaves the lips of hopeful politicians....
It's a model that even the insurance industry could get behind:
...Private health insurers are also central to the system as supplemental insurers who cover patient expenses that are not paid for by Sécurité Sociale. Indeed, nearly 90 percent of the French population possesses such coverage, making France home to a booming private health insurance market....
Whether Senator Baucus's vision eventually wins out in The Senate remains to be seen, but an
article in
The New York Times airs concerns about the economy - "even if a health overhaul does pass, it may not include the tough measures needed to bring down spending. Ultimately, the only way to do so is to take money from doctors, drug makers and insurers, and it isn’t clear whether Mr. Obama and Congress have the stomach for that fight. So far, they have focused on ideas like preventive care that
would do little to cut costs."
Do these "tough measures" address the fact that we spend more money than we should (or need to) on health care? Dutton admits health care in France is expensive. "At $3,500 per capita it is one of the most costly in Europe," but the price for our inefficient and broken system is "$6,100 per person in the United States." Kennedy succinctly counters the cynics who fret about the price tag:
What I haven't heard the critics discuss is the cost of inaction. If we don't reform the system, if we leave things as they are, health-care inflation will cost far more over the next decade than health-care reform. We will pay far more for far less—with millions more Americans uninsured or underinsured....
This would threaten not just the health of Americans but also the strength of the American economy. Health-care spending already accounts for 17 percent of our entire domestic product. In other advanced nations, where the figure is around 10 percent, everyone has insurance and health outcomes that are equal or better than ours. This disparity undermines our ability to compete and succeed in the global economy. General Motors spends more per vehicle on health care than on steel....
The United States is the greatest country in the world, but we don't have the best health care. That is an
embarrassment. It's a burden on the economy, and it's a burden on families. When millions of Americans cannot afford to be healthy it's
injustice. Opponents of reform often talk about freedom and choice. Dutton points out something that these opponents need to remember:
The link between employment and health security is a historical artifact whose disadvantages now far outweigh its advantages. Economists estimate that between 25 and 45 percent of the US labor force is now job-locked. That is, employees make career decisions based on their need to maintain affordable health coverage or avoid exclusion based on a preexisting condition.
That is not a statistic that supports the freedom inherent in a small government role. It's time to mend this crack in our liberty. Universal coverage will expand opportunity in average Americans who aren't lucky enough to be born into a rich family or get elected to Congress and will make the pursuit of happiness much easier. Let's hope this is the year that The Federal Government will finally provide every American the chance to be healthy regardless of the conditions that he or she is born into.